New Cumberland, PA · 17070 Mon–Fri 7:30 AM – 4:00 PM Open Now

New Cumberland's Most Trusted Auto Repair Family-Owned Since 1984

Honest diagnostics. Fair prices. No upsells, no pressure, no condescending dealership runaround. Just the neighborhood shop your parents trusted — and now you can too.

BOOK IN 60 SECONDS · 24/7 Schedule Service Online CALL NOW — OPEN TODAY (717) 731-9648
4.8 / 5
200+ GOOGLE REVIEWS
State Certified
INSPECTION STATION
Family Owned
COMMUNITY FOCUSED

Skip the phone tag.
Book your bay in 60 seconds.

Book online and we'll confirm your appointment within a few hours. We do our best to accommodate urgent requests — just let us know in the notes. Ideal for night-shift healthcare workers and anyone who'd rather not call during a meeting.

Book any time, 24/7
Request a slot whenever — we'll confirm within a few hours.
Text confirmation + reminders
No surprise no-shows, no phone tag.
Free to cancel up to 2 hrs before
Life happens. Reschedule with one tap.
Prefer a person? Call (717) 731-9648 — we pick up.
4.8
GOOGLE · 220+ REVIEWS
42yrs
Serving New Cumberland · Since 1984
Same·Day
when we can
We strive for same-day service
Written
Estimate
Before we touch a wrench

If it rolls, brakes,
or blinks — we fix it.

We're a full-service independent shop. No specialties, no corporate flowchart telling our techs what they can and can't touch. If you're not sure we do it, call and ask. Odds are, we do.

Most Common
01

General Repair

Brakes, belts, batteries, suspension — the day-to-day work that keeps your family moving.

Call First
02

Urgent & Emergency Repairs

Can't wait? Call us first — John will find a way to get you in as soon as possible. Ideal for healthcare workers, commuters, and working families who can't afford to wait.

Scheduled
03

State Inspection & Emissions

Licensed PA inspection station. In-and-out in under an hour when you schedule ahead.

Honest Quote
04

Check Engine Diagnostics

We tell you what's actually wrong — and what can wait. No padded work orders.

Warrantied
05

Brakes & Rotors

Pads, rotors, calipers, lines — full brake service with parts-and-labor warranties. Stop sooner, stop quieter.

Repair First
06

Exhaust Service

Mufflers, catalytic converters, flex pipes, welds. We fix exhaust leaks that other shops tell you to replace the whole system.

From $59
07

Oil Changes & Tune-Ups

Conventional, synthetic blend, full synthetic. Plugs, filters, belts, fluids — the routine maintenance that keeps small problems small.

All Season
08

A/C & Heating Service

System diagnostics, recharges, compressor work, and blower repairs. Warm in January, cool in July.

$89 Flat
09

Pre-Purchase Inspection

Buying used? Bring it by. $89 for a full bumper-to-bumper before you sign anything.

Everything a dealership isn't.

We're not trying to sell you a new car. We're trying to keep the one you love on the road — for another 50,000 miles, or another decade.

The Question
Leahy's Auto
The Dealership
01
Who greets you
John himself. No service advisor, no revolving door of techs — he'll remember your name next time.
A service advisor with a monthly sales quota.
02
How you get the quote
Written estimate before we touch a wrench. We call if anything changes.
A printout of 14 line items, half of them flagged "recommended".
03
The upsell problem
If your cabin filter is fine, we don't replace it.
Cabin filter. Every. Single. Visit.
04
Labor rate
$118/hr — posted on the wall. No surprises.
$180–$220/hr — buried in the invoice.
05
After the repair
12-month / 12,000-mile parts & labor warranty on most work.
Whatever the manufacturer's minimum is.
06
If something's wrong
Drive back. We'll look at it today. No appointment.
Next available Thursday. Between 8 and noon.
The Leahy's Promise
"If I wouldn't do the repair on my own mother's car, I won't recommend it for yours."
— JOHN FISHER, LEAD MECHANIC & SHOP MANAGER · NEW CUMBERLAND, PA
(717) 731-9648

Deep roots. One shop.
Zero corporate nonsense.

Jerry Leahy started this business in 1984. Today, it's run by John Fisher — a New Cumberland resident who knows your streets, your commute, and your neighbors.

We remember your name. We remember your car. We keep notes on what we've done, what we're watching, and what can wait. You're not a work order here — you're a neighbor, and we treat every car like it belongs to one.

1984
Year founded
40+ yrs
Serving New Cumberland
John Fisher
Your neighbor & your mechanic

Real people. Real cars. Real fixes.

4.8 / 5 · 220+ reviews
Verified on Google